Erin is twelve years old. For three years, she has been asking her parents for a dog. Her parents have told her that they believe a dog would not be happy in an apartment, but they have given her permission to have a bird. Erin has not yet decided what kind of bird she would like to have.

1. Erin’s parents like birds better than they like dogs
2. Erin does not like birds
3. Erin and her parents live in an apartment
4. Erin and her parents would like to move

This family scenario question clearly indicates the apartment living situation is the only fact directly supported by the text, while other options introduce unsupported assumptions about preferences.